Question:
Whats a Linked Comment on Youtube?
Michael
2011-03-25 12:10:49 UTC
i got this 2 times , while watching the same video , my comment appeared up on the top of the comments below the linked comment tab , even though i didn have any thumbs up, what the hell isthat?
Thirteen answers:
2011-03-25 12:19:32 UTC
A linked comment is when someone replies to your comment, it shows up as a linked comment. Log out of youtube and go to the same video and you wont see your comment linked.
2014-10-17 11:59:43 UTC
In the URL for the video, there is a comment ID that causes this to show up. Here is an example URL to a video:



https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N7l5VYrNLe4&feature=gp-n-y&google_comment_id=z131cbzrmzv3h5i5d04cdl2wtt3tydnjlf4



See that google_comment_id= value there? That's the thing that causes a comment to have a "linked comment" indicator.



Now, how to get a URL with a linked comment is a different question. Mine showed up because I got a Google+ notification about the comment. When I clicked on the notification, that was the URL for the notification. Clearly, Google+ wanted me to see which comment it was notifying me about.



Change the URL to not have the comment ID in it and the "linked comment" marker will be gone.
Matthias
2014-06-14 08:39:55 UTC
Everyone here is wrong. I'm a web developer and I've confirmed that it's in fact very simple:



When you go to a YouTube video, it has a URL. The URL can also point to a specific comment (by having something like &google_comment_id=z121znkozmeghfnge0xxxxfb5kjfsnqrcfc in the URL).



The phrase "Linked Comment" means literally "the comment referred to in the link (the URL).



For example, I got a Google notification that someone commented on my video. I click that link. It links to that comment. That comment appears as "linked comment" because the notification was linking specifically to that comment.
?
2014-12-30 21:20:38 UTC
Matthais (and Anonymous who also posted the vid) is/are broadly correct.



As I understand, simply "Linked Comment" shows up _when you have arrived at a video watch page via a URL that links to a specific comment_.



Thus if one clicks on a link from YouTube regarding a new/comment for approval, the specific comment in question is shown as the linked comment.



Similarly, if one chooses to Share a specific comment against a YouTube vid, then any clickers on that shared link will see the specific comment that you shared shown as the Linked Comment.



The more shrewd readers would be right to infer that when you want to both comment on a vid and share that vid with your (social network) friends, you're best to:

1. Make your comment on the vid and await its publication.

- Some vid publishers may choose to approve comments prior to their publication, in which case if you don't see it appear immediately, good form to wait 24/48hrs for publisher to approve.

2. When you see your comment on the vid appear (pretty much immediately if publisher has enabled), choose to Share _the comment_ (nowadays you do this by copying the link you can get from _when_ the comment was posted. E.g. I posted a comment a couple of weeks ago, where I see "2 weeks ago" against the comment on the vid's watch page, that's the link to copy and share).

3. Publish the shared comment to your social network(s).

4. Joy.

Anyone clicking on your link to the vid will see your comment foursquare right at top, as it should be. :)



Hope that helps.
techone
2015-09-03 06:04:46 UTC
Google marks those comments as linked comment if it is coming from Google+. If any viewer comments on your YouTube video from Google+ page, that comment will be marked as linked comment in YouTube. Even you may not see reply option for all linked comment because owner of that Google+ profile has restricted replies on Google+ settings. To verify further, go to your viewer's Google+ page and locate your video where he has commented, you will not see 'Add a comment' box.
Speechless
2014-06-16 16:44:34 UTC
The answer about the owner of the video is wrong. I'm the owner of some videos, and I see "linked comments" on some of them that I never replied to or liked.
2014-07-25 16:38:02 UTC
It's actually when the owner replies to you through Google+, and the conversation is held in Google+ itself. You can reply to that conversation, but it will not show on the Youtube page.
newhaveninc
2014-02-07 05:45:23 UTC
All these answers so far are WRONG- watch this video and you will know what linked comments are and how they were placed there. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cVCWQjt-exM Each linked comment is in fact a great quality back link to that commentors website.
?
2014-10-02 12:12:29 UTC
Latest Coupons for Web Hosting companies! See the Top ten web hosts for the 2014 and coupons to work with some of these merchants. Start your website with the best!!

- Find Discount Code here: http://bit.ly/1osYtgQ



#godaddy #server #hosting
2011-03-25 12:12:09 UTC
the owner of the video liked your comment
ZzBrandonzZ
2011-03-25 15:03:06 UTC
Its when the owner of the video replies to your comment :)
west coast best coast
2011-03-25 12:13:24 UTC
great question. i've gotten that a few times too
Lê Việt Quân¸
2014-09-24 02:48:43 UTC
http://greenplanet.com.vn/


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...